One of the questions I get asked over and over is how to have a natural, responsive, loving, relaxed relationship with food while also honoring your need for structure.
Women who ask me this question have typically spent some time in a weigh and measure program – weighing, measuring and writing down everything they eat. While this structure creates safety and helps stop a pattern of bingeing or food addiction, it also gets tiring over time. It can also easily lead to food obsession – even though you may be externally free from overeating, you don’t feel internally free. (You may be filled with worry, fear, anxiety or control on the inside.) You may even start to resist this structure as it feels punitive.
That was my experience.
On the other end of the spectrum, these same women find that an “eat whatever you want” or intuitive eating approach doesn’t work either. They end up eating too much sugar, starchy carbs, and processed foods, which then excacerbates the very bingeing patterns they’re trying to heal. That was my experience, too! When I gave myself total free rein, I ended up right back in sugar addiction.
What to do? The answer lies in balance, and paradox. You want to combine a loving, responsive relationship with food with the structures that enable you to honor your intentions to feed your body with love.
It’s good parenting. A good parent combines unconditional love with loving limits. We do the same for ourselves with food.
Being compassionate with yourself, unconditionally loving yourself, loving food, and acceptance does not mean that you throw all boundaries or “rules” out the window. It’s how you go about implementing them in your life that’s the difference between support and suffering. Are your choices coming from love, wisdom and care? That’s support. Are they coming from fear, rigidity, a desire to control, or aversion? That’s suffering.
Here’s how to do it, an idea that originally applied to parenting, from Sharifa Oppenheimer, author of Heaven on Earth: Imagine your food container as a clay pot. On the outside of the pot are the rules, structures, and boundaries that make you feel safe. Inside the pot there’s a lot of room – freedom – to grow, breathe, move, adapt, and respond.
This is how I do it – the outside of my pot looks like this:
1. Eating breakfast within an hour of waking.
2. Eating regularly – every few hours.
3. Balancing my meals with a mixture of protein, fat, and unrefined carbs.
4. Doing my best to minimize or abstain from sugar, my trigger foods (these are foods that I’m allergic to, like gluten) and other refined foods (for me, this includes white flour and dried fruit.) I overeat and binge on these foods every single time. Removing these foods from my diet alleviates the up and down that I experience on every level – emotionally, physically and spiritually – when I eat them.
These structures and rhythms, the outside of my pot, keep my blood sugar stable, help me feel grounded, safe and secure. They lower the cortisol (stress response) that’s one of the biggest contributing factors to overeating.
The inside of my pot, the intuitive eating component, looks like this:
1. Letting myself choose from a wide variety of foods when I eat. Asking myself, what do I want to eat?
2. Letting myself choose among many different options for the fat, protein and unrefined carbs component of my meals.
3. Relishing and enjoying my food, savoring it, letting myself eat foods that I like. Food is not my enemy.
4. Adapting to the different needs, seasons, and more that effect how I eat. Listening to the rhythms of life that ask for different ways of nourishing myself. Listening to what my body (not my mind – two totally different things!) is needing.
How these two components work together is like this:
Right now I’m dealing with fatigue, burn out and stressful life circumstances. When I listen to my body (the intuitive eating component), this is what it tells me: I need rest. I need grounding. My response: eating lots of dense, grounding foods – winter veggies, root veggies, nuts, fat, and animal protein. They nourish me body, mind and spirit.
I’m also reaching out for support (lining up friends to talk to when I’m wanting to overeat, for example) so that my food container – my structures – are as strong as possible. When I’m under stress, the simple carbs and sugars call my name. I know this, so I’ve tightened my structure, so to speak, to support myself. I’ve also made eating regularly a priority, a non negotiable. This is not a time to be more “flowy” with when I eat.
At other times in my life, when life is more flowy and less stressful, I need less grounding foods. I may respond with eating more lighter foods. My structures may soften a bit.
It’s a beautiful dance, an ebb and flow, a responsiveness (vs. reactivity) that says: How am I feeling right now? And what do I need? Given what is, what do I need to do to care for myself?
And then believing, really feeling at the deepest level, that I am a precious, precious soul who deserves that loving kindness…..who can then act on those promptings to care for my body with kindness, wisdom and tenderness.



Yes!!!!! Thats just where I am right now. I live my life watching my weight and generally being obsessed with it all, but Have recently come accross Zoe Harcombe. I have for the last six months been on the Dukan Regime, but again began to get hungry and put it back on, worse scenario. Now am following what she says and tryin to get out of the constant worrying. But no sweeteners, sugar or otherwise. Eaing natural foods, three meals a day and just generally trying to relax around food.
OMG!(for lack of a better superlative). Karly I so appreciate you and your message. . I needed this so much tonight. I plan on reading it many times. I am really struggling right now with my ebb and flow and with balance. Doing things in a “balanced” way is so out of my comfort zone and so uncomfortable for me. I am trying to do this with my eating and exercising but it feels so uncomfortable. I want so bad to go to from one extreme to the other!!! I am realizing that food has always been my maternal comfort to myself. My mother was not affectionate or terribly comforting growing up. My father was not either except when he had a few drinks in him. I love my husband very much but he has the exact same issues when it comes to affection and comfort. So therefore where do I get that need filled? Food. I don’t know how to change this. The need will always be there and I do not expect the people in my life to change. That would be setting myself up for major dissappointment. So what do I do? I have yet to find a replacement that works. I have tried so hard through the years. I quit drinking because that .became problematic and I still regret I had to do that. When I think of sarting tot make better choices in order to live a healthier life I think about the things I will lose that bring me comfort i.e. coffee, diet sodas, sugar, carbs, etc. And I feel like my warm blanket is being taken away. I don’t want to give it up and yet my size 10 skirt is too tight and I hate that too. I am spinning and I deeply appreciate the ability to share here!
So well said Karly! I agree. The writing, weighing and measuring just immerses me in the food and the addiction. It is too much structure and I feel like I’m putting too much energy into illness rather than health.
As corny as this sounds, thank you for always looking into my heart and mind and expressing it into words.
I am so grateful for you.
Wow I love this. I am coming from a background of OA and tyring FA to finally put an end to my sugar addiction and compulsive overeating, but I have decided it just doesn’t work for me. I know that I cannot eat sugar. I am working on if there are other foods that I need to add to that. I also know that I binge eat on cashews. So the these foods are my never eat foods.
I can’t stand the structure of commiting to a food plan for the day, only eating a very structured times and weighing and measuring everthing I eat. I need the ability to eat my lunch within in a range of time. I need the ability to eat what sounds good at lunch, not what I wrote on paper the previous day.
I love the way you describe this Karly. This is exactly what I need to do. It is a work in progress.
Thanks so much for all your wonderful insight and encouragement so that I can learn to love food while still having structure around what I eat.
Dearest Carol,
You are so welcome. I appreciate you and all of the ladies for pushing me to express this paradox in a way that is easy to understand, and most importantly, doable! You have inspired me to dig deep, and I’m so grateful.
I’m going to follow up on this post with another one this week that explains how to build that food container – particularly in the beginning. Getting those new structures up and running – that’s a lot of the work, isn’t it?
I love hearing how you’re growing and taking care of yourself. Even more than food, Carol, that is a huge, huge victory! You are loving and caring for the precious, worthy soul that is you. How that makes me happy.
In love, Karly
Hi Carol!
I did FA for 1 year and lost a lot of weight but it was the craziest thing I ever did. I disliked the time restraints and the daily calls I was forced to make. It made me feel like a child and that I could not make my own choices. I have gained all the weight back unfortunately but i will never succomb to that type of rigidity again. You and I have so much in common!
Lizanne